New Article: Second City: Part 1: Shugenja and Battle Maiden

Moderators: Shinjo Dalu, Ide Yesugei, Shinjo Magistrates

Post Reply
User avatar
Shinjo Dalu
White Guard
Posts: 577
Joined: Sat Aug 14, 2010 2:22 pm
Location: The Real Dublin, Ireland

Tue Sep 13, 2011 4:59 pm

Up on the front page (with images)

--------------------------
Hello fellow Pony players! Since the moderators have asked us to write articles for the Unicorn forums, I am going to focus on writing on the cards from various expansions that would be good for you to keep in mind. With the release of Second City this week, I will be previewing various cards from that particular expansion. I will mostly discuss cards in contrast with other Emperor cards in mind but if there is some sort of important Celestial combo I will mention it as well. This part will preview Shugenja and Battle Maiden cards with the following part previewing Tactician, Commander and Miscellaneous cards (Dare I say a scout deck?).

Part I: Shugenja and Battle Maiden

Shugenja

http://l5rsearch.com/images/cards/motominggwok.jpg

Moto Ming-Gwok (Common) - Our 4th EE legal shugenja, Ming-Gwok doesn't exactly wow our socks off. Barring the return of Temple of Death or a similar stronghold his ability is "dead" so to speak. At 4F for 9 gold he is also slightly over costed (was their any reason he shouldn't have been 8 gold?). Good news is once you get his ability going, he is decent going forth and will work well with Skipping the Puddle. Overall, he might make early shugenja decks, but quickly come out for more efficient personalities.

http://l5rsearch.com/db/search.cgi?titl ... e%20Puddle

Skipping the Puddle (Rare) - If any card is going to make our Shugenja theme, this is it. I highly recommend going out of your way to pickup 2 to 3 of these if you have any urge to play a Shugenja build. As a Kata, you put it into play as a limited action, reducing the Surprise factor it could bring otherwise. What it does though is make your opponent play a completely different game. Since all of our Shugenja that have been previewed so far are Water and Cavalry, let the hijinks and trickery begin! One of the most important rules to remember is the new Spell attachment rule for EE which can be preformed off this kata. So, you can move in, attach a spell and then use that spell on your opponent. Channeling the Fallen (gencon promo), Pearl of Rage (FL), Strength of the Tsunami (SeC), and any spell that has a battle ability worth playing. Skipping the Puddle also can be used on any preformed actions including those on weapons! (Cursed Relic or Wrymbone Katana anybody?) Stronghold abilities such as Journey's End Keep can also be used (a combo that also cant be negated by Effortless Counterattack). Worst case scenario, Skipping the Puddle negates a send home action without giving up your action to do so. Highly recommended card to acquire to start the arc.

http://l5rsearch.com/db/search.cgi?cmd= ... rd_id=9491
http://l5rsearch.com/db/search.cgi?cmd= ... rd_id=9509

Bo of Water (Common) and Katana of Fire (Rare) - Two spells with very similar function. The spells themselves do not have actions besides the Limited action to create a weapon attachment. Double attachment cards are a benefit and a curse in their own ways. Benefits include counting as two attachments for actions that target cards without attachments. These attachments can also be attached to any personality. Iuchi Yupadi can also use the "blank spell" to give naval to somebody. However, a few bad points for them also exist. The "meat" of the attachment is a 0GC weapon. Cards like Bonds of Coins can be used to destroy the weapon, which is the main point of the spell. Also, attaching these spells in battle with the rulebook equip action will not be optimal since you cannot use the limited action then. Bo of Water works well with our Shugenja, seeing as the attachment allows us to contribute force while bowed after using a card like Pearls and Spirits.

http://l5rsearch.com/db/search.cgi?cmd= ... rd_id=9461

Strength of the Tsunami (Rare) - High Force, high versatility, powerful spell. 6 Force makes any of our Shugenja province crushing and gives them a multitude of abilities. The battle straighten and/or send home is highly useful as a proactive or defensive ability. When used in combination with a Pearls and Spirits it makes for a very large range attack with the spell. The Battle ability is great for removal if it is successful. My only concern is that it's proactive battle is not as powerful as the other 8 gold cost range attachments. Its versatility and ejection ability make it a good option to go to for awhile.

http://l5rsearch.com/db/search.cgi?cmd= ... rd_id=9460

Mastering the Elements (Rare) - Unique copy spell. 4th copy of any spell. Issue with it is that if I spend 8 gold on a Strength of the Tsunami, it can still be destroyed by Bonds of Coins. Probably more effective with the double attachment spells (Bo of Water and Katana of Fire) as their weakness was already the zero gold cost.


Battle Maiden

http://l5rsearch.com/db/search.cgi?cmd= ... rd_id=9496

Utaku Liu-Xeung (Rare) - Brings what battle maidens have been missing: proactive battle actions. She also has a decent force gaining trait that works well with her inexperienced version. Wish the send home action was equal or less personal honor and that her force was a base 5 (9 gold for 4 force isnt great military numbers). However with a base 4 PH and the paragon and cavalry keywords she fits perfectly into current Battle Maiden decks.

http://l5rsearch.com/db/search.cgi?cmd= ... rd_id=9494

Utaku Mai (Uncommon) - Sound of Thunder the personality. 5 HR is a little harsh (though my WoH deck will love her for Strength of Paragons) but you get a solid 4F 4 Chi 4 PH for 6 gold after you gain 1 honor. Her ability is great too for leaving behind extra force at home or waiting at another battlefield and seeing if you need her. The Wind Never Stops is extra lolz with her but I doubt we will get that back for EE.

http://l5rsearch.com/db/search.cgi?cmd= ... rd_id=9510

Effortless Counterattack (Rare) - Chase rare from SC. So many cards are granting additional actions and Shugenja can straight do it as a rule book action with spells. With Iron Will in our paragon decks this card is an auto include combo with it. My Testing has shown people are starting to not take the additional action after an Iron Will in fear of getting their additional action canceled. Best of all, the additional action this card has isn't awful either. It is proactive send home or defensive send home on your own guy with no attachments. Battle Maiden decks are going to have so much negate it is actually going to be pretty funny between Iron Will, Effortless and Know no Fear.

http://l5rsearch.com/db/search.cgi?cmd= ... rd_id=9498
http://l5rsearch.com/db/search.cgi?cmd= ... rd_id=9525

Spirit of the Paragon (Common) and Surety of Purpose (Rare) - Two similar cards with the same battle ability (Bow a personality) with slightly different pluses and minuses. Spirit has a higher range of possible personality targets (equal or lower force or personal honor) but requires you to play it pre-battle. Granted it is reusable, but how often are cavalry paragons going to be opposed in battle (maybe once a game?). It can give paragon to a personality, which is an ability to keep an eye on but since paragon does little on it's own, that is not really that much of a benefit. Surety of Purpose can be used while bowed and is a surprise out of hand. It also gives a small honor gain. Either of these card in total are not very powerful and will be replaced early into the arc as more cards become playable, if they are played at all. EE has already shown a plethora of unbow making these cards weak already.

Part II to be soon!

User avatar
Mophat
White Guard
Posts: 120
Joined: Sat Aug 21, 2010 10:21 am

Wed Sep 14, 2011 8:03 am

Great article I thoroughly enjoyed it.

The only thing I wanted to point out is you're error on combining Skipping the Puddle and Journey's End Keep. As Effortless Counterattck says negate all it's effects it would even negate the cannot be delayed or negated effect on JEK before it would become active. JEK will only stop cards that specifically negate or delay movement not the effects of the entire action.
Nebraska Kotei 2009 Winner
The Blessing of Pan'ku Storyline Tournament Winner

Image

Ide Kirik
White Guard
Posts: 168
Joined: Tue Aug 24, 2010 4:18 pm

Wed Sep 14, 2011 8:48 am

I like this "more articles" trend I'm seeing. A very thorough and useful analysis of the SC rollout. Can't wait for part II.

A note, however: Effortless Counterattack can negate the Skipping the Puddle / Journey's End combo. It negates all effects of the action, including the effect that says the movement can't be negated.

User avatar
Moto Naranbaatar
White Guard
Posts: 386
Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2010 8:08 pm

Wed Sep 14, 2011 12:49 pm

Seals wrote:(was their any reason he shouldn't have been 8 gold?)
You know that keyword? Unicorn Clan? That costs 1 more gold. :(
Image Image

User avatar
Ide Yesugei
White Guard
Posts: 1179
Joined: Fri Aug 13, 2010 7:34 am
Location: Calgary Alberta
Contact:

Wed Sep 14, 2011 2:33 pm

Greetings all,

I thouht I would add the Unicorn Customer Satisfaction Index for the cards in this review just to lend a little background on what people thought of the card in the week of preview.

Shugenja

Moto Ming-Gwok 17/23 Positive =73.9% satisfaction

I tend to see that he could be a really key persnonality or utter chaff. No real middle ground on this guy. Love him for humor value though.

Bo of Water 15/22 Positive= 64.4% satisfaction

You can put this one in the many are not as fond of bow actions as you show the arguemtn as to why they are underpowered to start with with all the straigthen tech around. I think most missed the combo with Yupadi as this is a potential 2 for 1 attachement card to avoid all the naked kill.

Battle Maidens

Utaku Mai 25/25 Positive 100.0% satisfaction

Seems eveyone thought this peep was a good idea.Whats not to love...

Utaku Liu-Xeung 26/31 Positive = 83.9% satisfaction

A good unique with underwhelming cost to stat ratio. Explained well as she some warts but no real flaws.

Spirit of the Paragon 15/22 Positive= 64.4% satisfaction

You could use this more if we had really good non paragons and I love Moto Xiao XP 'the lethal paragon". It may become better if there is ever a reason for Shug/Pargaon synergy.

Looking forward to part 2.
Diplomat * Host * All around fun guy

Image
"Smiling makes me happy and others nervous"

Image

User avatar
Moto Seals
Emerald Champion
Posts: 492
Joined: Thu Aug 12, 2010 10:59 pm

Wed Sep 14, 2011 9:23 pm

Mophat wrote:Great article I thoroughly enjoyed it.

The only thing I wanted to point out is you're error on combining Skipping the Puddle and Journey's End Keep. As Effortless Counterattck says negate all it's effects it would even negate the cannot be delayed or negated effect on JEK before it would become active. JEK will only stop cards that specifically negate or delay movement not the effects of the entire action.
Yeah I thought I read Journey's End as reading that this action cannot be negated but in reality it was the movement cant. Doesn't really weaken the combo by huge amounts (if at all) but still something to keep an eye regardless.
Image

User avatar
Horiuchi Meimei
White Guard
Posts: 750
Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2010 11:17 am
Location: Saint Paul, MN

Sat Sep 17, 2011 9:56 pm

I can't wait to try out the Death Priests in EE. Ming-Gwok has a good buddy in the Onyx Champion Takasho, who can provide a bit of fuel for the former.
"The Mantis have power over thunder and lightning but there is more to the storm than that."

2012 Thunder Bay Kotei Winner
2013 Minneapolis Kotei Winner
2014 Green Bay Kotei Winner
2014 Thunder Bay Kotei Winner
Lots of t16/t8 and a few t4

Post Reply
  • Information
  • Who is online

    Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest